Sell your comic books & trading cards to Nostalgible
From a single key issue to a lifetime collection, we buy Golden, Silver & Bronze Age comics, graded and raw keys, vintage sports and non-sport cards. Every submission gets a free, detailed, item-by-item appraisal based on current fair market value — and we'll compete with any written offer from a dealer or auction house.
- Free appraisalNo cost, no obligation
- Prepaid overnight labelFully insured — no driving
- We competeBring any dealer or auction offer
- Paid fastNo consignment wait, no seller fees
how selling your collection works
- 1Tell us what you have
Fill out the form below with a description, key items and photos (a shared album link works best). A rough list is fine to start.
- 2Get a detailed appraisal
We review every key and grade, then send an item-by-item breakdown with current fair market values drawn from recent public sales — so you see exactly how we got to our number.
- 3Receive a firm offer
Already have an offer from a dealer or auction house? Send it over — we'll compete for your collection. No pressure, no obligation.
- 4Get paid
Accept the offer and ship with the prepaid overnight label we email you — high-value insurance covers every book in transit. Get paid promptly once items are verified.
comics & cards we buy
Photo tips for the fastest appraisal
- Front and back of keys and high-value items
- Slab labels clearly visible (cert numbers help)
- For big collections: a few shots of the boxes plus your best 10–20 items
- Note any restoration, damage or missing pieces
selling to Nostalgible: questions
Is the appraisal really free?
Yes. There's no charge and no obligation to sell. You'll get our item-by-item values whether or not you accept the offer.
How do you decide what to offer?
We start from fair market value — what each item has actually been selling for recently in public sales, adjusted for grade and condition — then make an offer on the collection. We show you the numbers so you can see how we got there.
Will you really compete with an auction house?
Yes. Send us any written offer or auction estimate you've received. Auction houses charge seller fees and make you wait for the sale and payout — we pay promptly, with no fees taken out.
Do you buy single items, or only big collections?
Both. A single high-grade key is as welcome as a basement full of long boxes.
How does shipping work?
You never have to drive anywhere or meet up. Once you accept an offer, we email you a prepaid overnight shipping label, and high-value insurance covers every book in transit, door to door with tracking. Any size collection, from anywhere in the U.S.
How do I get paid?
Payment is sent promptly once items arrive and match the description — we'll confirm the method with you when we make the offer.